Get our Daily Newsletter to stay updated on education policies, research, jobs & more.
/
/

Teachers in West Bengal have opposed the state government’s proposal to create a university service commission for centralised recruitment, arguing that the move could weaken the autonomy of universities in appointing teachers. The proposal covers state-aided universities and related higher education institutions.
The state higher education department has proposed the West Bengal University Service Commission, with an 11 member commission constituted to examine the proposal and frame expert guidelines for the proposed body. The move has triggered concerns among teachers over who would control universities appointments.
As reported by The Telegraph, teachers argue that individual universities are better placed to decide their academic requirements because institutions differ in their areas of expertise and academic priorities. They currently recruit teachers under the broad eligibility and selection requirements prescribed by the University Grants Commission (UGC).
Also read | ICMR invites proposals for centres for advanced research (CAR), funding up to Rs 15 crore
Calcutta University professor Sagarmoy Ghosh said universities need the freedom to determine the kind of teachers they require. He argued that this institutional choice helps a university “evolve as a centre of excellence”.
Jadavpur University professor Manas Ghosh said the proposed system could give the state greater control over appointments and subsequently make transfers easier. He said universities were the appointing authorities and that the proposed arrangement “would not stand legal scrutiny”.
The concerns come as the West Bengal Inter University Transfer Bill, passed by the state assembly on September 10, is yet to receive the Governor’s assent. Teachers had earlier opposed the legislation, arguing that transfers should not be carried out without the consent of the universities.
Jadavpur University professor Parthapratim Roy said the existing UGC framework allows university subject experts to play a significant role in selection. He pointed to differences between departments, saying one university may need expertise in astrophysics while another may have different requirements.
The Telegraph also reported concerns among teachers that centralised recruitment could bring restrictions similar to those proposed for schoolteachers recruited through the school service commission. A Presidency University teacher said there was apprehension that “similar restrictions will be imposed” on university professors if the new commission is introduced.
Get key education news, research, and job opportunities in your inbox.